Someone had raised some questions on an earlier post about the journal Asian Philosophy. Does Asian Philosophy subject papers to blind review? I have seen a lot of good articles in Asian Philosophy over the past two years, but this does not mean they are vetted properly. I have also seen articles there that were rather weak, and ignored much of the current literature on their topics. As a way of figuring this out, please respond to the questions below, if relevant:
1. Have you gotten comments on a paper submitted to Asian Philosophy in the past two years?
2. Have you gotten anything other than an acceptance from Asian Philosophy in the past two years?
3. Have you been asked to review a paper for Asian Philosophy in the past two years?
Thanks for any help. Anonymous posts are of course welcome, with valid email.